611 W. Union Street
Benson, AZ 85602
(520) 586-0800

member support line
M-F 5pm-8pm
24/7 weekends/holidays

AzCH Nurse Assist Line


611 W. Union Street
Benson, AZ 85602
(520) 586-0800

AzCH Nurse Assist Line


powered by centersite dot net
Women's Health
Basic InformationLatest News
Can a Computer Program Help Docs Spot Breast Cancer?Diabetes Drug Might Help Women With Preeclampsia Prolong Their PregnancyCommon Hormone Disorder in Women Costs U.S. $8 Billion a YearSexual Assault Could Affect a Woman's Long-Term Brain HealthMigraines and More Severe Hot Flashes Could Be LinkedMore Women Turning to Marijuana Products to Help With MenopauseDepression During Menopause: How to Spot It and Treat ItPandemic Has Many Women Holding Back on Motherhood, NYC Study FindsIs Hysterectomy Always Needed for a Common, Painful Gynecologic Condition?Your State's Laws Might Save Your Life If Breast Cancer StrikesMom-to-Be's 'Leaky' Heart Valves May Pose More Danger Than ThoughtMore College-Educated Women Are Having Children Outside of MarriageAI May Not Be Ready to Accurately Read MammogramsPandemic Brought Big Drop in Breast Cancer Screening in Older, Low-Income WomenWomen May Find It Tougher to Quit Smoking Than MenFor Better Breastfeeding, 'Lactation Consultants' Can HelpCOVID Vaccine Safe, Recommended for Pregnant Women, CDC SaysCould Women's Health Decline Along With Their Height?Women Less Likely to Get Best Care for Deadly Form of StrokeHRT Could Raise Odds for AsthmaLeading U.S. Ob-Gyn Groups Urge COVID Vaccines for All Pregnant WomenAcne Can Take Big Emotional Toll on WomenVitamin D May Lower Black Women's Odds for COVID-19Mom's Weight-Loss Surgery Lowers Many Pregnancy Complications, Raises OthersPregnant Women Need to Take Care in Sweltering Summer HeatAre Antibiotics Really the Answer for UTIs in Women?Stronger Hearts, Better Outcomes in Pregnancy: StudyCould Menopausal Hormone Therapy Reduce Women's Odds for Dementia?Screening Often Misses Endometrial Cancer in Black WomenAHA News: Pregnant Mom's Diet May Influence Baby's Cardiovascular HealthPandemic Delays in Screening Mean More Breast Cancer Deaths Ahead: StudyUrinary Incontinence Can Affect a Woman's Mental HealthCOVID Vaccine Doesn't Infiltrate Breast MilkGap in Breast Cancer Survival for Black, White Patients Shrinks, But Not by EnoughCost a Barrier to Cervical Cancer Screening for Many U.S. WomenAlcohol Still a Threat in Too Many American Pregnancies: StudyWomen's Cancer Screenings Plummeted During PandemicPandemic Day Care Closures Forced 600,000 U.S. Working Moms to Leave JobsNo Sign Prior COVID Infection Affects a Woman's Fertility: StudyFertility Drugs Won't Raise Breast Cancer RiskMigraines Tied to Higher Odds for Complications in PregnancyWomen, Take These Key Steps to Good Urological HealthAre Women Absorbing Toxins From Their Makeup?Race Doesn't Affect Risk for Genes That Raise Breast Cancer RiskHealthy Levels of Vitamin D May Boost Breast Cancer OutcomesHeavy Drinking Could Lower a Woman's Odds of ConceptionAHA News: Asian and Pacific Islander Women May Be at Greatest Risk for Preeclampsia ComplicationsFibroid Pain, Bleeding Is Driving Thousands of Women to the ERA Woman's Diet Might Help Her Avoid Breast CancerBreast Cancer's Spread Is More Likely in Black Women, Study Finds
Questions and AnswersLinksBook ReviewsSelf-Help Groups
Related Topics

Medical Disorders
Wellness and Personal Development
Mental Disorders

Pandemic Day Care Closures Forced 600,000 U.S. Working Moms to Leave Jobs

HealthDay News
by By Amy Norton HealthDay Reporter
Updated: Jun 29th 2021

new article illustration

TUESDAY, June 29, 2021 (HealthDay News) -- When child care centers were forced to close in the pandemic's early months, hundreds of thousands of American working mothers lost their jobs, new research shows.

The study is just the latest illustration of the toll the pandemic has taken on working women in the United States.

Over the first 10 months of the U.S. pandemic, more than 2.3 million women left the labor force, according to the National Women's Law Center. That compared with just under 1.8 million men.

That was, in part, because many job losses were in industries where women make up much of the workforce. On top of that, working mothers — more than fathers — faced the difficulty of having kids home from school or day care.

The new study looked specifically at the impact of pandemic child care closures.

It found that in states that had closures in spring 2020, women's job losses were particularly acute. In contrast, the employment decline among men was similar to that of men in other states.

Nationwide, the gap amounted to about 611,000 lost jobs among working mothers.

"The effect was concentrated among women with young children," said lead researcher Yevgeniy Feyman of the Boston University School of Public Health.

That, he said, suggests that child care closures, themselves, fueled many of the excess job losses.

That is likely the case, agreed Rasheed Malik, who studies child care policy at the Center for American Progress, a nonpartisan policy institute in Washington, D.C.

"Prior to the pandemic," he said, "there was already a strong relationship between local availability of child care and women's participation in the workforce."

The pandemic only worsened the longstanding problem of child care "deserts," Malik said. Those are areas across the country — typically low-income — where working parents lack affordable, quality child care options.

Child care centers did reopen in closure states by June 2020, according to Feyman's team. But while many women and men did go back to work, women still lagged behind as of December 2020, the study found. They were less likely than men to be employed, and their employment rate remained below its pre-pandemic level.

Simply allowing child care centers to reopen didn't necessarily solve families' problems.

For one, Malik said, an estimated 10% of programs closed for good. And at those that did survive, staff reductions meant fewer families could be served.

"Getting back into the system wasn't just a matter of going back to the program you'd been in," Malik said.

The findings are based on data from a monthly labor force survey. It included nearly 49,000 U.S. adults, including more than 13,000 from states where child care centers shut down by April 2020.

Employment among men and women in all states dropped sharply in April 2020, but women in states with child care closures saw the steepest drop-off. The likelihood of women being employed during the closure period was 2.6 percentage points lower, compared to men.

That translated to 611,000 job losses among 23.5 million working mothers, the researchers estimated.

To Feyman, one implication is that American workers need better paid family leave, and a "cultural shift" where not only women, but men, take it.

Malik pointed to some fundamental issues that make finding reliable child care so difficult, pandemic or not.

Unlike public education, he said, the child care system is "market-based" — with programs concentrated in more affluent areas where families can afford the cost.

"We think of it as a market failure," Malik said. "We don't have public school deserts, but we do have them in child care."

To make quality care accessible to more families there must be some level of government subsidy as well as assistance to low-income families, he said.

That "investment in families" would be repaid in parents' increased productivity and the educational and social benefits young children gain from being in high-quality programs, Malik said.

Another problem is the field's generally low pay and high turnover.

"These are difficult jobs," he added. "The work is rewarding, but definitely not financially rewarding."

Malik said that low pay is rooted in "historical bias" that undervalues the work of women, who make up the vast majority of the child care workforce.

"It's about time we honor the decades of hard work they've given us," Malik said.

The findings were published online June 25 in JAMA Health Forum.

More information

The nonprofit Zero to Three has resources on child care.

SOURCES: Yevgeniy Feyman, PhD student, health services research, Boston University School of Public Health; Rasheed Malik, senior policy analyst for early childhood policy, Center for American Progress, Washington, D.C.; JAMA Health Forum, June 25, 2021, online